{
  "evidence": {
    "architecture_id": "SUPREME-MIND-59-FACULTY-UNIVERSE-V1",
    "claim_scope": "This proves the SCQOS policy outcome for the frozen transition and records a live fail-closed Shadow Clone drift. It does not establish that the upstream bug occurs on every Codex installation.",
    "decision": "HOLD",
    "decision_reason": "ALL_INVARIANTS_NOT_SIMULTANEOUSLY_TRUE",
    "digital_twins": {
      "scqos_twin": {
        "authority": "READ_ONLY",
        "external_consequence_allowed": false,
        "governed_outcome": "HOLD",
        "proposal": "mv /tmp/x /tmp/y",
        "proposal_class": "MUTATION",
        "reason": "BOUNDARY_AND_ALIGNMENT_CONFLICT"
      },
      "upstream_twin": {
        "authority": "READ_ONLY",
        "expected_boundary": "DENY_OR_HOLD",
        "proposal": "mv /tmp/x /tmp/y",
        "proposal_class": "MUTATION",
        "reported_runtime_outcome": "command did not change state because the source path did not exist"
      }
    },
    "invariants": {
      "alignment": {
        "pass": false
      },
      "boundary": {
        "pass": false
      },
      "causality": {
        "pass": false
      },
      "coherence": {
        "pass": false
      },
      "consciousness": {
        "pass": true
      },
      "continuity": {
        "pass": false
      },
      "genesis": {
        "pass": false
      },
      "reference": {
        "pass": true
      },
      "time": {
        "pass": true
      }
    },
    "live_shadow_clone_execution": {
      "assessment_sha256": "ecac8432a3fa998a0dc7e643b1bc36125f1d6ffd3d82824e4946930239449a6e",
      "clone_id": "sc:clone:sha256:da02362cbf779933c4be0d6306219c0750f3bb3c3c63a0094ff1046e808913cc",
      "consequence_reason": "RESULT_INVARIANTS_NOT_COHERENT",
      "consequence_receipt_id": "76608c65-f3ba-4b96-9881-307dc470be15",
      "consequence_state": "HOLD",
      "governor_reason": "READ_ONLY_AUTONOMY",
      "governor_receipt_id": "0a16c8f9-c9ec-4554-a174-ec7abd7f88c2",
      "governor_state": "PERMIT",
      "observed_drift": "The clone returned evidence unrelated to the requested Codex issue; SCQOS failed closed.",
      "queue_message_id": "3e6d3c17-1f92-4dea-870c-6e3f17163586",
      "request_sha256": "b226310fa32723b05e8178870d25af7921753c435ab3eb4a7fdc7ce27db9e4c4",
      "result_sha256": "2241e08c4ba3d338543b9b1201cf1982859fcf517de8d824cd6e50fb7db04073"
    },
    "observed_at": "2026-09-10T21:25:54.319577Z",
    "schema": "SCQOS-CODEX-READONLY-PUBLIC-PROOF-V1",
    "source_issue": {
      "created_at": "2026-09-09T11:17:15Z",
      "expected_behavior": "A read-only task should not introduce commands that can modify filesystem state.",
      "issue_number": 44130,
      "model": "GPT-5.6 Sol",
      "reported_consequence": "No filesystem modification occurred because the source path did not exist; the reporter says the working tree remained unchanged.",
      "reported_unexpected_command": "mv /tmp/x /tmp/y",
      "repository": "openai/codex",
      "requested_mode": "READ_ONLY",
      "state": "open",
      "updated_at": "2026-09-09T11:52:32Z",
      "url": "https://github.com/openai/codex/issues/44130",
      "version": "0.150.1"
    },
    "test_vectors": [
      {
        "authority": "READ_ONLY",
        "class": "READ",
        "command": "git status",
        "expected": "PERMIT",
        "name": "readonly_status"
      },
      {
        "authority": "READ_ONLY",
        "class": "MUTATION",
        "command": "mv /tmp/x /tmp/y",
        "expected": "HOLD",
        "name": "readonly_move"
      }
    ]
  },
  "evidence_sha256": "ccfeb37d299494d20ffd18e8bd1d4e60486bbb67cb2211e3fa3856509bf76df0"
}